Our country is often, and rightly, called technologically backward. But it was not always so — before the collapse of the Soviet Union, technologies developed in Ukraine were considered the best in the world. What opportunities have we missed?
Today the world sees our country only as a resource base. This applies both to raw materials (agricultural products, metals, chemicals and so on) and to technology. The best Ukrainian scientists now work mostly on foreign projects, and the country's largest IT companies do not build products of their own but write code to specifications from companies in the US and the EU. As a result, neither our own intellectual capital nor our scientific base is growing. Here is the paradox: according to the IT Ukraine Association, our country ranks 5th in the world in IT outsourcing, yet when experts are asked to name even five Ukrainian developments known around the world, they fall silent.
It was not always like this. A mere 30 years ago we had a powerful IT industry and a strong scientific base. The starting point is 1949, when the first computer in Europe was assembled in Kyiv. By the mid-1960s our computers were ahead of developments elsewhere in the world. Vesti has collected the best IT projects of the Soviet period, found out what became of them and what Ukraine needs to do to regain its former glory.
A computer based on ternary logic
Uses logic similar to human reasoning in its calculations
In 1959 an event took place that could have changed the design of modern computers: the Setun computer was built, performing operations not in binary logic (yes, no) but in ternary logic (yes, no, maybe). At the same time, it remains compatible with two-valued logic — logical operations on "known" values give the same results. Now that work on artificial intelligence is under way all over the world, computers of this type are considered the most promising in this respect. The point is that such reasoning is closer to human thinking than the "false/true" logic standard for computers. Moreover, the world's leading companies are developing quantum and optical computers based on machines that use ternary logic.
The creator of this unusual computer is Nikolay Brusentsov, a native of Dniprodzerzhynsk (today he heads the computer laboratory of the Faculty of Computational Mathematics and Cybernetics at Moscow State University). Some fifty of these machines were produced in the Soviet Union, but by the end of the 1980s they had been scrapped for metal.
There are plans to use ternary computers to build artificial intelligence and ultra-powerful computers
Electronic government
Lets a state get rid of bureaucrats by abandoning paper documents
All EU countries and the US are now actively introducing and developing e-government systems. Yet the idea was conceived not in the West but in Kyiv. In 1964 Academician Viktor Glushkov proposed the OGAS project (the Nationwide Automated System for collecting and processing information for the accounting, planning and management of the USSR's national economy) — one of the first global networks in the world. The plan was for the internet to be created right after OGAS (of course, it was not called that at the time, but the idea was similar).
The essence of the project was to move the entire country's document flow into electronic form, to manage the economy online all the way from the machine tool to the ministry, to optimize technological, economic and organizational processes, to reorganize management and to develop the information technology industry. In other words, to create so-called paperless informatics and an information society. It even envisaged abolishing paper money and replacing it with electronic money. In the 1980s the project was shut down for political reasons and because of Glushkov's death. Today attempts are being made in Ukraine to revive it.
Had the project for electronic management of the country been launched, Ukraine could well have become the birthplace of the internet
A machine for engineering calculations
One of the world's first small-sized computers
In the mid-1950s Kyiv scientist Viktor Glushkov began work on solutions for engineering calculations — at the time, there were no specialized computers for this purpose anywhere in the world. In 1963 the Promin machine was launched; its distinctive features were memory on metallized cards and the introduction of stepwise microprogram control (the foundation of any operating system). The next step was the creation in 1964 of the MIR series of computers, which led the world in the speed of analytical transformations. In addition, a group of scientists led by Glushkov created Analitik, a machine language as close as possible to human language (meaning the language of mathematical terms, not everyday speech). Another feature of the machine was that it output its results to a "printer" (a Zoemtron electric typewriter was used), stored information on magnetic cards (diskettes) and had a graphic display with a light pen (a forerunner of the stylus). In size it was already closer to a personal computer (it fit in an office) than to its predecessors, which took up an entire floor.
Had the MIR computer been developed further, Ukraine could have created the world's first personal computer
Computer vision technology
Developed in Kyiv back in the 1970s and now considered fundamental to robotics
Exactly a year ago a landmark event took place in the Ukrainian IT market: Google acquired the Ukrainian company Viewdle, which specializes in computer vision systems, for $34 million. This is a unique face and object recognition technology that is widely used in search. Google has already launched its image search based on this technology: when picture files are uploaded into the search bar, it looks for places where similar images appear. This technology is key to all the devices of the future, since it underpins a computer's ability to recognize faces and license plates, tell living objects from inanimate ones, and so on. Without it, the development of robotics is impossible.
The technology was developed back in the 1970s at the Kyiv Institute of Cybernetics. Only recently did Ukrainian IT entrepreneurs Yegor Anchyshkin and Yuriy Musatenko manage to turn it into a commercial product. Its author is physicist Mykhailo Schlesinger (now a professor at the Department of Information Security of the Institute of Physics and Technology at KPI). In Soviet times such systems were developed for the military-industrial complex.
Google's image search already runs on technology developed by Ukrainians
The world's first quantum computer
Considered science fiction until a Ukrainian took it on
The quantum computer — a machine with fantastic computing power (tens of thousands of times greater than that of a conventional computer) — is considered one of the most important technologies of the future. Five years ago its emergence was seen only as a hypothetical possibility, but in 2011 the Canadian company D-Wave not only showed the first working prototype but also sold it for $10 million. And in May 2013 Google and NASA bought a second unit for $15 million. Serial production of such computers is planned in the near future.
One of the four founders of the Canadian company D-Wave Systems is Alexandre Zagoskin, a scientist from Kharkiv who emigrated to Canada in the mid-1990s. It was his idea to develop quantum processors based on superconducting elements. Zagoskin managed to attract investors and assemble a team of scientists from the former USSR (for example, a significant contribution was made by Evgeni Il'ichev, a professor at the Institute of Photonic Technology in Jena). In just five years, through joint efforts, they turned science fiction into reality thanks to work that had begun back in our country.
A quantum computer's processing power exceeds that of a conventional computer tens of thousands of times
Viktor Glushkov — a Ukrainian futurologist
Academician Viktor Glushkov is rightly regarded as the founder of Ukrainian cybernetics. He had a very clear vision of the future and described it in the futurological forecasts he made back in the 1950s and 1960s.
Why our IT developments went unused
A non-market approach
In the USSR everything was tied to the military-industrial complex. To get money to start work on a given project, one had to go through numerous bureaucratic procedures, which took a lot of time. On top of that, in the early 1980s a source of income such as revenue from personal computer sales and the computer games industry was ignored — home users were able to pay far more than could be obtained from the budget. By the time the first home PCs began to be produced, the moment had already been lost. For example, the IBM-compatible Poisk PC appeared only in 1991 and cost a whole thousand rubles. Yet demand for affordable home computers was enormous — as can be judged from sales of clones of the British ZX Spectrum (priced at 100 rubles), which were selling like hot cakes by the end of the 1980s.
Poor-quality components
The peculiarities of the planned economy meant that PC developers had no opportunity to choose component suppliers, and the range of available parts was too limited. In other words, an engineer could design the best solution in the world, but there was nothing to build it from. Under such conditions there could be no talk of more sophisticated hardware architecture, better manufacturability or lower prices. Industrial design was out of the question altogether.
The collapse of the USSR
Roman Khmil, head of the IT company Ciklum, says that between 1991 and 2001 virtually all programmers left the country because they could not find work here. They made a major contribution to the development of IT around the world. Examples include Max Levchin, who created the PayPal payment system; Gregory Shenkman and Alec Miloslavsky, the founders of Genesys, who created a computer-telephony integration system; and Oleg Gutsol, the creator of the hugely popular photo service 500px.
How Ukraine can join the IT leaders
State support in promotion
"If the IT industry receives support at the state level, our companies will easily push competitors aside in the global market," says Ruslan Olkhovsky, head of Softengi, a Kyiv-based IT company specializing in outsourcing. "In the spring I was at the CeBIT trade fair and saw how the Poles do it," the expert continues. "They had a separate pavilion bringing together the stands of all Polish IT companies, and the fair hosted presentations aimed at advertising Poland as an IT brand. Their country spent money on this information campaign and is now getting it back in the form of growing tax revenues from IT companies based in Poland. We need to follow the same path. Because in the global IT market nobody knows our country."
Conditions for business
"For us to be considered a player in the global market, we need to improve the transparency of doing business (by cutting income tax, since salaries make up 80% of costs in the IT business and IT companies currently register their employees as sole proprietors. — Ed.), the investment climate, specialists' command of English and IT, and the quality of education in narrow specialties. Under such conditions, within 5–10 years we could become a second Israel in terms of the number and quality of programmers, and the IT industry would bring around $10 billion into the budget," believes IT expert Yuriy Syvytsky.
Market protection
Virtually all of the world's leading IT companies grew up on government projects. In our country, by contrast, the state often hands contracts worth hundreds of millions of hryvnias to foreigners, effectively investing in someone else's economy. This practice must stop.