As recently as last autumn, Apple topped the list of the world's most valuable companies by market capitalization.
Its shares peaked in September 2012. But sales began to fall as early as November. And in January this year, after the quarterly report, rumors started circulating about the company's impending collapse.
So what is happening at this once-thriving corporation: temporary difficulties, management missteps or outside interference? Some experts believe Wall Street had a hand in the situation. Others see the cause in the lack of genuinely new products, arguing that consumers are only being offered updated versions of old ones. Obozrevatel looked into the situation around Apple.
Shares and capitalization collapse
Apple's share price began falling last autumn, and in March this year it did not rise above $440 per share. In September 2012 the shares reached a high of $705.70 apiece, and Apple was the world's most valuable company, with a market capitalization of over $600 billion. By February–March 2013 its capitalization had dropped to $394.45 billion, and Apple ceded its former leadership to the American oil corporation ExxonMobil (market capitalization: $417 billion).
The giant's shares collapsed after it published its results in January 2013: the quarterly report was the worst in years. In the first quarter of the 2012–2013 fiscal year, which ended on December 29, 2012 (in the US the fiscal year begins on October 1 — ed.), the company increased its net profit only marginally — by just 0.8% — despite growing sales of iPhones and iPads.
Incidentally, sales growth was the slowest since 2009. Sales rose by only 18%, to $54.5 billion, below analysts' forecasts of $54.9 billion. Meanwhile, in October–December 2012 the corporation sold 47.8 million iPhones (29% more than in the same period a year earlier), and iPad sales rose by 48% to 22.86 million units.
Adding fuel to the fire was negative news from Asian component makers about reduced orders for Apple parts. In particular, the company cut its purchases of iPhone 5 components almost in half. Experts began talking about falling demand for the smartphone and the strengthening position of Apple's competitors: South Korea's Samsung Electronics and China's Huawei Technologies and ZTE.
Some analysts even predicted that Samsung could take the lead thanks to its huge product range. Apple, which had previously held the lead thanks to new technologies, released only the iPhone 5, iPad mini and iPad 4 in 2012 — devices that, in the specialists' view, are not really new, but merely updated versions of previously offered models.
Incidentally, as Apple's shares fall, Google's value is rising. The Android operating system already dominates the market.
Investors, too, have grown indignant about Apple's situation. Greenlight Capital, a major US hedge fund headed by David Einhorn and an investor in the company since 2010, filed a complaint against Apple with the US Securities and Exchange Commission. The main reason for the claim is the decline in Apple's share price, which is costing shareholders millions of dollars.
At the same time, according to some international financial analysts, the drop in the share price in the first quarter of the 2012–2013 fiscal year was caused precisely by investors' dissatisfaction and disappointment with Apple.
For instance, Fortune analyst Philip Elmer-DeWitt, who spent several days analyzing trading in Apple shares on the stock exchange, noted that the company's securities were being "dumped" deliberately. He believes that about 800,000 Apple shares worth $300 million were thrown onto the market at a knocked-down price in the final seconds of trading. In his view, this was done on purpose, as most investors had concluded that no profits from Apple should be expected any time soon.
Ups and downs
Apple has not always been at the height of its fame. A look at its share price from 1981 to 2012 reveals both ups and downs.
Apple shares have traded on the NASDAQ electronic exchange since December 1981; the initial price of one share was only $4 at the time. The all-time low of $1.44 per share was recorded in July 1982. Between 1981 and 1998 the price fluctuated, reaching $9.30 in 1998.
During the global crisis the share price fell by 55%, and from 2009 to 2012 it rose eightfold, from $83 to $705. The latter figure is an all-time high, reached in September last year. On March 14 this year the share price dropped to $428.35.
Some analysts link the company's past achievements to the name of Apple's founder, Steve Jobs. But, as its history shows, the corporation's successes were never constant and were periodically followed by setbacks.
For instance, low sales in the 1980s forced Jobs to cut staff (forty people were laid off). In 1985 Apple's profits began to decline, a trend that continued almost until 1997.
The cause was a disagreement between Jobs and the company's new top manager, John Sculley, which forced Apple's founder to leave the company he had created. The founder returned to Apple after a 12-year break, and in 2001 he developed the iPod audio player. In 2007 the iPhone touchscreen smartphone came out, followed in 2010 by the iPad tablet. These products boosted profit growth, and in summer 2011 Apple became the world's most valuable company by market capitalization. The company held on to that position until November 2012, despite Jobs's death in October 2011.
New products are no rescue
The company has been launching new products for many years. We have already mentioned last year's new releases, with the exception of Apple TV. In January this year Apple confirmed that it plans to start producing fourth-generation iPad tablets with a full-size Retina display and 128 GB of storage.
As Serhiy Kadulin, director of Apple's distribution department in Ukraine (Electronic Resource Company), told Obozrevatel, when it comes to plans for 2013, Apple traditionally does not announce new products in advance. "We don't know either what interesting products will appear or when to expect them," Kadulin said.
Yet it is precisely Apple's focus on technological novelty that some analysts blame for the fall in its share price. In their view, the market is quite saturated, and users are increasingly hard to impress.
Investors, for their part, are concerned that the company is producing groundbreaking products and technologies less and less often, and that sales drop immediately after a new product is released. In their opinion, only revolutionary developments can revive sales growth.
Notably, in October 2012 the new iPad mini wiped $18 billion off Apple's market capitalization. Market participants felt at the time that the device's announced price — from $329 to $659 (depending on the memory and the cellular module) — was too high.
Incidentally, the iPad mini's modest display specifications became the main complaint of critics and buyers. The company responded with a statement that the next generation of the tablet, the iPad mini 2, would get a higher-resolution screen.
Here is a comment from one of the tablet's users: "Everything the iPad mini has is Apple's production leftovers. It doesn't have powerful modern hardware, it doesn't have a Retina display, and it doesn't run for 10 hours or more on battery. The iPad mini's price turned out to be much higher than that of competing Android devices. I think Apple miscalculated with the iPad mini."
Wall Street rules capitalization
So what caused the "dark days" of a company that was so successful until recently? One IT industry specialist, who wished to remain anonymous, believes that Apple's hard times have several causes, in particular falling iPhone 5 sales, a large number of defects in the new smartphones (chips and scratches), the failure of its mapping platform, and the high price and lack of innovative solutions in the new iPad mini.
"Android and Samsung are breathing down Apple's neck and treading on its heels, which worries market experts," the independent expert noted. "Apple's standing was also hurt by the recent dismissal of Scott Forstall, whom many considered a worthy successor to Steve Jobs. Besides, the company has no real innovations — it only updates old products, which weakens its position."
Artur Orudzhaliev, editor-in-chief of AIN.UA, believes that after the death of Jobs, Apple's legendary and brilliant creator, perceptions of the company have changed, "but so far only in people's heads." "The company makes superb products, and nothing indicates that the situation has changed," Orudzhaliev told Obozrevatel. "It's just that over the last few years Apple was so good at surprising consumers that now, when the company releases 'simply an excellent product' with great market prospects, many people start saying 'Apple isn't what it used to be' and 'This would never have happened under Jobs.' Even though the products will sell extremely well."
In the expert's opinion, in today's world a company's capitalization is ruled not by the product or by a brilliant developer, but by an investment manager on Wall Street (the New York Stock Exchange) who, as the recent crisis showed, understands nothing about real business. "There can be no forecasts," Orudzhaliev noted. "The company lost a quarter of its value in a single year, even though it didn't make a single bad product. The bad product is the brains and decisions of investment managers."
For his part, Anton Marrero, an IT expert and member of the supervisory board of an IT consortium, believes that since Jobs's death Apple has not lived up to consumers' expectations. "Buyers expect this company to deliver not just high-quality products, but radically new, revolutionary solutions, and none have appeared," the expert told Obozrevatel. "It is hard to explain to existing customers why they should swap a smartphone that works perfectly for a new model, while new consumers have to be won in a fight against numerous competitors from China and South Korea."
According to Marrero, the company's mistake was its patent war with competitors: although it won from a legal and financial standpoint, it lost in terms of public perception. "In effect, after an extremely detailed examination, the court acknowledged that Apple's products differ little from Samsung's, dispelling an image that had been built up over years," the expert said. "From the consumer's point of view, the logical question is: if they're the same thing (even if the Koreans copied the solutions), why should I pay more?"
An even bigger mistake was releasing a smaller, more affordable version of the iPad under the same brand — this destroyed a self-sufficient brand and the image of the device that had taken hold in consumers' minds, Marrero noted. In his view, it would have been better to come up with a new name for the new device, even one with the "i" prefix. Under Jobs, Apple won by creating fundamentally new product categories.
However, it is too early to bury the company or to talk about its future collapse on the market, the expert observed. After all, its products still sell better than any competitor's, and the company itself remains the most valuable technology company in the world.
Speaking about Apple's future, Marrero noted that it is not yet clear in which sector new to the company it will be able to compete successfully, since a race to cut prices or the release of cheap devices is a road to nowhere (as Nokia has proved). "Most likely, the company will take the path of fundamentally new services for consumers: for example, its devices will turn into personal assistants equipped with artificial intelligence and connected to powerful computing centers," the IT expert predicted. "In that case, it will have to cooperate with other corporations that collect user data — the largest search engines and social networks — and take data from them for processing."
Source: Obozrevatel