A new public services portal, iGov.org.ua, was presented in Ukraine a few days ago.
According to the initiators of the project — PrivatBank top manager Dmytro Dubilet and former adviser to the Ministry of Economic Development Jaanika Merilo — it will allow every Ukrainian to handle all their dealings with the state apparatus online without leaving home, from obtaining a certificate of no criminal record to registering a car with the vehicle registration office.
The developers were anonymous volunteer IT specialists. We tried out the services on offer and also found out when Ukraine will have a fully fledged electronic government.
Yet another attempt
To begin with, every government since around 2002 has announced the imminent launch of a public services portal. The current Cabinet promises to launch electronic government by 2017. But so far, the only result of these loud promises has been the Ministry of Economic Development's portal, launched in 2012, which, despite the several million hryvnias spent on it, has never started providing any services and remains merely an information resource (it tells you which paper documents you need to obtain a service and where to get them).
Oleksandr Ryzhenko, head of the State Agency for E-Governance, explained that problems arose with the next stages of rolling out electronic services: first, institutions are not ready to accept documents electronically, and second, the technical processes (information, ordering, result, payment) have not been set up. "At the moment, only the registration portal (on the Ministry of Justice website, where you can register a business. — Ed.), the administrative services and taxpayer accounts (on the State Fiscal Service portal, which let you file reports with the tax office. — Ed.) and electronic construction permits (on the State Architectural and Construction Inspectorate website. — Ed.) are up and running," he explained.
A list, but no services
At the presentation, it was announced that the portal brings together almost all the services that our state provides to citizens and businesses. Of these, 9 services are already available (marked with a green circle), 47 are to be introduced in the near future (yellow circle), and 492 services are being worked out for the longer term (marked in gray). We went to the portal to try out at least one service in action. But, alas, for now the portal looks like a simple business-card website, and although Dmytro Dubilet put the value of the resource at millions of dollars, the design is unimpressive, to put it mildly.
Most of the services marked in green are of no interest to ordinary people (for example, checking the status of an application for special subsoil use permits). The option of obtaining a certificate of no criminal record online could make life easier for those applying for civil service jobs. But the service is available only to residents of Dnipropetrovsk, according to the portal. When we tried to use it, we got an "HTTP Status 404" error.
Web developer Ihor Zabrudsky, whom we asked to assess the portal, said it was too early to call it finished. "The services that work on it (for the construction sector) were available electronically on other portals before — this is not the volunteers' achievement. And doing everything else takes not only the efforts of IT people but work in close cooperation with the state. And there is no such cooperation, because government agencies have no right to open up their registers. That requires a comprehensive project and legislative changes. The idea itself is right, but I don't see a breakthrough," he notes.
Viktoriya Herasymovych, deputy director of the information technology department at the Ministry of Economic Development, says her ministry is not against providing services electronically, but officials simply have no legal basis for doing so. "The Ministry of Economy is working on these issues. But in our country the procedures for providing most services are established by law, and laws are a matter for the Verkhovna Rada," the official noted.
A service not for everyone
To use the portal's services, you need either to obtain an electronic digital signature or to get a bank card and register in the BankID citizen identification system. PrivatBank, Oschadbank, Bank Mykhailivsky, Platinum Bank and Fidobank have already joined the system. As experts explained to us, BankID is the main asset of the iGov.org.ua project.
After all, practically everyone has a bank card, whereas to obtain an electronic digital signature you have to travel to one of the key certification centers and fill in paper forms. Practice shows that simple solutions are always more viable. But it is too early to be optimistic about the electronic public services project as a whole — the laws need to be changed and the databases put in order.
How do you get an electronic digital signature?
To do this, you need to apply to the accredited key certification center of the State Fiscal Service. The signature is provided free of charge. Download the registration card from cskidd.gov.ua, fill it in and take it, together with copies of your passport and tax identification number, to any tax office, where the certificate and keys will be written to your flash drive.
Opinion: administrative services should be handed over to the private sector
Anton Marrero, member of the Supervisory Board of the IT consortium Intecracy Group, explained how Estonia's e-government system (considered the most advanced in the EU) differs from what Ukraine is trying to do.
"Creating electronic services is one thing. Constantly maintaining and upgrading them is quite another," the expert says. Estonia solved this problem through a public-private partnership. It gave private companies access to the registers that serve as reference directories (all government agencies rely on them in their work). Private companies build user interfaces and provide access to the information. Estonia has 2,000 unique services, accessed through about 6,000 commercial systems — between two and five for each service. The price for all users is 1 euro per transaction (50 cents to the state and 50 cents to the company that developed, maintains and improves the service at its own expense). "All this has radically reduced the state apparatus and left no dark corners for corruption to spread. But trying to do everything with volunteers is doomed to failure. They will be building 500 services until the next Great Flood, because they have no motivation," the expert says.
Source: 01.ua